By Bill Bell
Is it human nature to assume the worst?
I find myself asking that question fairly often when reading stories about driving in Mexico. Something happens, someone posts about it, and before we have even established where or when it happened, the story has grown legs.
A possible scam becomes a confirmed scam. An encounter with someone described as a police officer becomes proof that the police are targeting tourists. A road blocked earlier in the morning is still being described as closed days later.
Sometimes the original poster was careful. They said “possibly,” “apparently,” or “this is what I was told.” Those words seem to disappear as the story gets passed along.
And suddenly, a rumour is being repeated as a fact.
I want the facts, especially when the news is bad
People who know me know that I try not to undersell the dangers and uncertainties of driving in Mexico. There are real problems. Accidents happen. Roads deteriorate. Scams happen. People have frightening encounters, and some suffer serious harm.
Pretending otherwise helps nobody.
But—and it is a big BUT—when a negative story comes along, I want as many facts as possible.
Where did it happen? When? Did the person telling the story experience it themselves? What exactly happened, and what part is their interpretation? Is there an update? Has the road reopened? Has someone checked with the office involved?
Those questions are not an attempt to dismiss someone’s experience. They are how we turn a worrying story into useful information.
There is a considerable difference between “Mexico is dangerous” and “A traveller reported this particular problem at this location on this date.”
One gives you something to worry about. The other gives you something you may be able to plan around.
Why do we add to the story?
I don’t think everyone sharing an alarming story is trying to mislead anyone. Often, they believe they are helping.
We want to warn our friends. We don’t want someone to get hurt because we kept quiet. A frightening story gets our attention, and passing it along can feel like the responsible thing to do.
But good intentions do not make the information accurate.
Sometimes we fill in details that were never there. Sometimes a story fits something we already believe, so we don’t question it very closely. And sometimes, let’s be honest, the dramatic version makes a better story.
“I’m not sure what happened here” doesn’t get quite the same reaction as “WARNING! NEW SCAM!”
Unfortunately, the second headline can travel a long way before anyone checks whether the first one was closer to the truth.
An experience matters. So does its limit.
If someone tells us they had an uneventful drive across Mexico, I’m pleased to hear it. But that does not prove every road is safe for everyone.
If someone reports a frightening encounter, I want to hear that too. But it does not automatically tell us how common that experience is, or what every other traveller will encounter.
Both accounts can be true.
The trouble starts when we take one person’s experience and turn it into a verdict on an entire country.
Mexico is a very large place. The road, the region, the time of day and the circumstances matter. So does the date of the information.
A report without those details may create plenty of discussion while offering very little practical help.
Ask questions without attacking the person
There is another side to this. People should be able to describe a bad experience without being shouted down by those who insist nothing bad ever happens in Mexico.
“I’ve driven that road for twenty years and never had a problem” does not mean someone else didn’t have one yesterday.
Equally, asking for a location, a date or clarification is not accusing someone of lying.
We should be able to say, “That sounds upsetting. Can you tell us exactly where it happened?” We should also be able to say, “This part has been confirmed, but that part hasn’t.”
That is a much more useful conversation than choosing sides between “Mexico is perfectly safe” and “You’d be crazy to go.”
Before you pass it along
Here is what I would ask people to do: read past the headline. Check the date. Find the original account if you can. Keep the words “possible” and “unconfirmed” when that is what the source actually said.
If it happened to a friend, say that. If you witnessed it yourself, say that. If you don’t know whether a road has reopened, don’t present an old closure as a current one.
And if you shared the warning, share the correction or the reopening too.
That last part matters. We are often very quick to spread the bad news and surprisingly quiet when the situation changes.
I want our groups to be places where people can report problems honestly and travellers can find information they can use. That means taking concerns seriously without making the story bigger than the evidence.
A serious situation does not need sensationalizing. It needs explaining.
I’m not asking for fewer warnings. I’m asking for better ones.
—Bill Bell

Leave a Reply